Welcome to the 4DR Clan Forum! You are currently browsing the forum as a guest, which gives you limited access. For more access, the ability to post, and to have your own account, we ask that you register (which you can do here).
So what I think I have found out based on my Wiimmfi friend rosters, is that if you add someone and they don't add you back, their mii will show up but it will always say that they're offline. I believe this is the case with Tim on my 4DR roster and MSX Sky on one of my other rosters.